What Are Toenails and Why Do We Have Them?
Toenails are hardened, protective plates made of keratin—the same tough protein found in fingernails and hair. These translucent structures grow from specialised cells in the nail matrix at the base of each toe, forming a resilient covering that serves multiple purposes in our daily lives.
While they might seem minor, toenails are sophisticated structures that evolved over millions of years to support our unique bipedal (walking or moving on two feet) lifestyle. Far from being useless appendages, they play essential roles in protection, balance, and overall foot health.
The Evolutionary Journey of Toenails
From Claws to Nails: Our Primate Heritage
Ever wonder why we have toenails? The answer comes from our long-ago relatives who lived in trees.
Our toenails used to be sharp claws, just like cats and dogs possess today. But millions of years ago, our ancestors needed something different. Living high up in the forests meant they had to grab onto branches without slipping and falling.
Sharp talons weren’t suitable for this job. So over time, these points slowly changed. They became flat and wide instead of needle-like and piercing. This gave our tree-dwelling relatives a better grip on limbs and helped them move safely through the canopy.
Later, when humans started walking on the ground instead of residing in trees, these keratin plates still helped us. Our early human predecessors travelled long distances over rocks, thorns, and rough terrain. Their nail coverings protected their toes from getting hurt, which was very important because they didn’t have shoes to wear.
So today, our toenails are still with us – a leftover gift from our tree-climbing past that once kept our ancestors safe.
Are Toenails Just Evolutionary Leftovers?
Unlike true vestigial structures such as the appendix, toenails serve practical purposes in modern humans. They help protect against cuts, infection, and other damage to toes, which have vulnerable vascular and nerve structures and small bones.
While we no longer climb trees like our primate relatives, toenails have found new ways to remain useful in our evolutionary journey.
The Important Functions of Modern Toenails
Protection and Defence
The most obvious function of toenails is protection. They guard the sensitive tissues and nerve endings at the tips of our toes from injury, acting as natural armour for the distal phalanx (the bone at the end of each toe).
Think about how painful it is to stub your toe. Now imagine doing so without the protective barrier of your toenail! The hard keratin surface absorbs impact and prevents damage to the delicate structures beneath. Anyone who’s lost a toenail (particularly the big toe) quickly learns to appreciate this protective function.
Structural Support for Your Toes
Toenails provide crucial structural support that enhances foot mechanics. They stabilise the soft tissue underneath, creating counter-pressure that helps distribute weight evenly across your toes when walking or running. This support is significant for your big toe, which bears significant weight during walking and plays a key role in balance and propulsion.
Enhanced Sensitivity and Feedback
Toenails also contribute to proprioception (your body’s position and movement awareness). Like fingernails, toenails enhance sensitivity by providing counter-pressure when your toe tips touch surfaces, improving feedback about terrain, and helping with balance.
This sensory enhancement, though subtle, assists with spatial awareness and helps you navigate uneven surfaces more effectively. This improved sensitivity can be crucial for athletes’ and dancers’ performance and safety.
Could We Live Without Toenails?
Life Without Toenails
Many people live without toenails due to injuries, infections, or medical procedures. While adaptation is possible, most report some challenges with balance, discomfort in shoes, and increased vulnerability to toe injuries.
People with lost toenails often experience problems with their gait, suggesting that these structures play a meaningful role in our biomechanics. The absence of toenails can also make the toe tips hypersensitive to pressure and more susceptible to infection.
Common Toenail Problems
Despite their benefits, toenails can sometimes cause problems. Ingrown toenails, fungal infections, and trauma-related issues can make these protective structures feel more like a burden than a blessing.
When toenail problems develop, professional care from a podiatrist is often the most effective approach. At Highett Podiatry, we specialise in treating ingrown toenails, fungal nail infections, and other conditions affecting these important structures.
Caring for Your Toenails
Proper toenail care is simple but essential:
- Cut nails straight across, not too short
- Keep them clean and dry
- Wear properly fitted shoes
- Inspect regularly for changes in colour or texture
- Seek professional help for persistent problems
Tiny But Mighty Protectors
Far from being useless evolutionary leftovers, toenails are important protectors, supporters, and sensory enhancers for our feet. They’re remarkable examples of how structures can adapt to serve new purposes as species evolve.
Next time you’re trimming those toenails, take a moment to appreciate these tiny shields that have been guarding your toes throughout human evolution. And if you’re experiencing toenail problems, don’t hesitate to book an appointment with our expert podiatrists.
Stay informed with our latest insights by visiting our blog.